Reconciliation of field strength to efficiency calculator with Boswell’s loop measurements

(Boswell et al 2005) discussed a small transmitting loop (STL) and offered predictions and measurements of performance.

Boswell’s loop is 1m diameter of 22mm diameter copper tube.

This article is a reconciliation of Calculate efficiency of vertically polarised antenna from far field strength with Boswell’s predictions, measurements and efficiency calculations.

Boswell-Fig06Above, Fig 6 from Boswell shows his prediction of the field strength of a 100% efficient loop at several distances, and measured field strength. He calculated efficiency from the difference between predicted lossless and measured.

Figures used for this article were scaled from the graph, so there is some scope for error in that process.

Screenshot - 25_11_2015 , 00_28_08

Above is an example calculation at 40m distance on 3.6MHz. The scenario is attached to the Example 3 button.

Screenshot - 25_11_2015 , 00_00_13

Above is a table of calculation results using the Norton t5 approximation built into Calculate efficiency of vertically polarised antenna from far field strength, and a comparison with Boswell’s calculated efficiency.

The reconciliation is best where standard deviation is small, and it is comforting that where standard deviation is small, the reconciliation is very good.

References / links

  • A Boswell, A Tyler, and A White. Apr 2005.  Performance of a small loop antenna in the 3-10 MHz band In IEEE Antennas and Propagation Magazine, Vol. 47, No. 2, April 2005.