I have written online and in many many emails that a very common failure of VNA measurements of components is the test fixture, and the standout problem is most often the length of connecting wires.
This article works a couple of theoretical designs based on a validated model and experience of building and measuring many baluns of similar or identical design. We will then look at extracts from a Youtube video by ferrite manufacturer Fair-rite and appraise the results.
Validated theoretical choke designs
FT240-43
It is possible to calculate a pretty good estimate of the impedance of a common mode choke wound on a #43 material ferrite core over 1-30MHz. Measurement of a real choke suggests an equivalent shunt capacitance to calibrate the model to measurement. Whilst I have given the generic name to this core, it is based on Fair-rite’s 5943003801 and Fair-rite’s published 2020 #43 mix characteristics. There are imposters, and they may be significantly different.
Let us take a practical example design and calculate the expected choke impedance and from that, the expected |s21|dB in a VNA series through measurement setup.
Above is a SimNEC model of a FT240-43 with 11t winding and 2.5pF equivalent shunt capacitance to calibrate the self resonant frequency. The model calculates and plots choke impedance, and |s21|dB in the series through measurement configuration shown. Continue reading VNA measurement – small is beautiful